Shenton Brokers
← Compare other insurers

Personal accident insurance

Lonpac vs MSIG personal accident insurance

As of 28 Oct 2026 (Singapore time)

Of the 9 examples both price, Lonpac was cheaper on 1, MSIG on 8. Your own answers can change the order, so get your own quote.

Lowest price on each example

Each insurer's cheapest plan for the example, with any discount it is running taken off.
ExampleLonpacMSIG
Accountant, S$200,000 coverS$303.60Personal CarePlus Standard (S$200,000)as at 11 Oct 2026S$322.73PA RecoveryPlus Gold (S$200,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
Sales executive who travels for work, S$100,000 coverS$171.20Personal CarePlus Basic (S$100,000)as at 11 Oct 2026S$154.78ProtectionPlus Silver (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
Technician, S$500,000 coverNo online priceNo online price
Class 1 job, S$50,000 coverS$171.20Personal CarePlus Basic (S$100,000)as at 11 Oct 2026S$125.35ProtectionPlus Silver (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
Class 2 job, S$50,000 coverS$171.20Personal CarePlus Basic (S$100,000)as at 11 Oct 2026S$125.35ProtectionPlus Silver (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
Class 3 job, S$50,000 coverNo online priceS$207.10ProtectionPlus Silver (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
You and your spouse, S$50,000 coverS$325.28Personal CarePlus Basic, me and my spouse (S$100,000 each adult; spouse 10% off)as at 11 Oct 2026S$238.17ProtectionPlus Silver, me and my spouse (S$100,000 each adult)as at 19 Oct 2026
You and 1 child, S$50,000 coverS$205.44Personal CarePlus Basic, me and my children (S$100,000; each child S$34.24, up to 3)as at 11 Oct 2026S$136.25ProtectionPlus Silver, me and my children (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
You and 2 children, S$50,000 coverS$239.68Personal CarePlus Basic, me and my children (S$100,000; each child S$34.24, up to 3)as at 11 Oct 2026S$147.15ProtectionPlus Silver, me and my children (S$100,000)as at 19 Oct 2026
Family: you, your spouse and 1 child, S$50,000 coverS$359.52Personal CarePlus Basic, family (S$100,000 each adult, spouse 10% off; each child S$34.24, up to 3)as at 11 Oct 2026S$238.17ProtectionPlus Silver, my family (S$100,000 each adult)as at 19 Oct 2026
Family: you, your spouse and 2 children, S$50,000 coverS$393.76Personal CarePlus Basic, family (S$100,000 each adult, spouse 10% off; each child S$34.24, up to 3)as at 11 Oct 2026S$238.17ProtectionPlus Silver, my family (S$100,000 each adult)as at 19 Oct 2026
1 child on their ownNo online priceNo online price

All prices include 9% GST.

These are example prices for the details above. Your own price depends on your answers.

Cover side by side

Each insurer's cheapest plan for accountant, S$200,000 cover: Lonpac Personal CarePlus Standard (S$200,000), MSIG PA RecoveryPlus Gold (S$200,000).
CoverLonpacMSIG
Accident medical expensesS$6,000 a year (TCM S$100 per treatment, up to S$750 a year)S$2,000 per injury; alternative treatment S$400 (S$40 a visit); mobility aid S$2,000
Hospital cashS$100 a day, up to 60 daysS$100 a day up to 365 days (doubled in ICU up to 30 days); S$100 a day for dengue, food poisoning or HFMD up to 50 days
Infectious diseases (e.g. dengue)Up to S$1,200 for 21 infectious diseases including dengue, Zika, HFMD and MERS; HIV through blood transfusion S$10,000Hospital income for dengue, food poisoning and hand, foot and mouth disease only
ExcessS$0.00S$0.00

Dearer plans from either insurer can cover more. Read the policy wording before you buy.

Discounts running today

More about each

See every insurer's price for your own answers, cheapest first.

Get your own quote

Questions people ask

Is Lonpac or MSIG cheaper for personal accident insurance?

Of the 9 examples both price, Lonpac was cheaper on 1, MSIG on 8. Your own answers can change the order, so get your own quote.

How does Lonpac's cover compare with MSIG's?

On each one's cheapest plan for accountant, S$200,000 cover (Lonpac Personal CarePlus Standard (S$200,000), MSIG PA RecoveryPlus Gold (S$200,000)): Accident medical expenses: Lonpac S$6,000 a year (TCM S$100 per treatment, up to S$750 a year), MSIG S$2,000 per injury; alternative treatment S$400 (S$40 a visit); mobility aid S$2,000; Hospital cash: Lonpac S$100 a day, up to 60 days, MSIG S$100 a day up to 365 days (doubled in ICU up to 30 days); S$100 a day for dengue, food poisoning or HFMD up to 50 days; Infectious diseases (e.g. dengue): Lonpac Up to S$1,200 for 21 infectious diseases including dengue, Zika, HFMD and MERS; HIV through blood transfusion S$10,000, MSIG Hospital income for dengue, food poisoning and hand, foot and mouth disease only; Excess: Lonpac S$0.00, MSIG S$0.00.

What discounts are Lonpac and MSIG running?

Lonpac: none to show. MSIG: 15% off; 20% off.